Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Response to "Bare White" by Liz Baum

1. Upon exploring the digital storytelling site, I chose to view a story under the Identity tab. I was surprised to see a video featuring a white artistic speaking about her own racial identity. Reflecting upon my initial reactions, she explains through thoughtful monologue and pictures that whiteness is often perceived as "normal" to individuals who share this racial identity and it is scarcely viewed as an identity at all. Baum's narrative primarily her response to a book she read "Why are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?" by Beverly Tatum. Tatum's book discusses white identity and suggests that white people do not think about their racial group. Baum reflects upon her own childhood and remembers a sea of white faces, dotted occasionally by vague images of individuals of other races.

2. The method of digital story telling would undoubtedly benefit the effectiveness of learning. Multimedia projects cater to several different types of learning and through a diversity of mediums, there is a greater chance that the overarching message will be understood by everyone. Students are given the ability to express their individuality in these products by including their voice and other creations that can reflect upon an topic that is of interest to them. This method of spreading ideas would be appealing to students because it is technology-centric and its method of execution is nearly limitless.

3. There were many attributes to this digital story that made it captivating but also some elements...or rather missing components...that lessened its effectiveness. The topic alone combined with the crisp images of a white lawn chair and her childhood photos reflect a good example of what is perceived as whiteness. However, although her narrative talks about a sudden revelation that she is a "white woman", she really does not explain these implications. The narrative seemed rather incomplete and it would have been interesting to hear how this realization of her white racial identity changed the way that she viewed herself and other races.

1 comment:

Emma Fitzpatrick said...

I completely agree! I wanted to like this story, but I just really didn't think it was a great digital stories; the photos didn't enhance her story, nor was her story complete. Glad someone else agrees! : ]